NATIONAL
INSTITUTES OF HEALTH, DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES
AUTHORIZATION:
Public
Health Service Act, as amended, Title III, Part A, Section 301;
Health Research Extension Act of 1985, Public Law 99-158, 42 U.S.C.
241; Title IV, Part B, Section 405; 42 U.S.C. 284; Part C, Section
455; 42 U.S.C. 285i; Health Omnibus Programs Extension Act of 1988,
Section 487(d); Public Law 100-607, 42 U.S.C. 288(d); Small Business
Research and Development Enhancement Act of 1992, Public Law 102-564.
To
support eye and vision research projects that address the leading
causes of blindness and impaired vision in the U.S. These include
retinal diseases, such as diabetic retinopathy and macular degeneration;
corneal diseases; cataract; glaucoma; strabismus; amblyopia; and
low vision and its rehabilitation. To increase understanding of
the normal development and function of the visual system; to understand
the causes of, and to better prevent, diagnose, and treat sight-threatening
conditions; and, to enhance the rehabilitation, training, and quality
of life of individuals who are partially-sighted or blind. To support
a broad program of basic vision research through grants and cooperative
agreements; to encourage high quality clinical research, including
clinical trials, other epidemiologic studies, and health services
research; to encourage research training and career development
in the sciences related to vision; and to sponsor scientific workshops
in high priority research areas to encourage exchange of information
among scientists. Small Business Innovation Research (SBIR) program:
To increase private sector commercialization of innovations derived
from Federal research and development; to encourage small business
participation in Federal research and development; and to foster
and encourage participation of socially and economically disadvantaged
small business concerns and women-owned small business concerns
in technological innovation. Small Business Technology Transfer
(STTR) program: To stimulate and foster scientific and technological
innovation through cooperative research development carried out
between small business concerns and research institutions; to foster
technology transfer between small business concerns and research
institutions; to increase private sector commercialization of innovations
derived from Federal research and development; and to foster and
encourage participation of socially and economically disadvantaged
small business concerns and women-owned small business concerns
in technological innovation.
TYPES
OF ASSISTANCE:
Project Grants. Place Cursor Here for Definition
USES
AND USE RESTRICTIONS:
Research grants and cooperative
agreements provide funds for salaries, consultant costs, equipment,
supplies, travel, patient costs, alterations and renovations, other
expenses, and consortium/contractual costs. The scientists and institutions
are under an obligation to expend grant funds prudently for the
purposes as stated in the application and award document. The Conference
Cooperative Agreement supports scientific meetings and workshops
in high priority research areas to encourage exchange of information
among scientists. The Core Grant is intended to enhance an institution's
environment and capability to conduct vision research, to facilitate
collaborative studies of the visual system and its disorders, and
to attract scientists of diverse disciplines to research on the
visual system. Career development awards include the Mentored Clinical
Scientist Development Award, Mentored Patient-Oriented Research
Career Development Award, the Mentored Scientist Development Award
in Research Ethics, and the Mid-career Investigator Award in Patient-Oriented
Research. Clinical Vision Research Development Awards are intended
to help investigators develop the staff and other resources needed
to enhance programs of clinical vision research through the application
of epidemiology and biostatistical methodology to clinical problems.
The Clinical Study Planning Grant is designed to support the development
of an applied clinical research plan. Small Grants for Data Analysis
provide limited support for meritorious research projects that involve
secondary analysis of research data generated from clinical trials,
population research and other applied clinical vision research projects
supported by the Institute. Small Grants for Pilot Research provide
limited support to allow investigators to collect preliminary data
in feasibility studies for which a successful outcome would have
a major effect on vision research. Bioengineering Research Grants
(BRG) support basic bioengineering research whose outcomes are likely
to advance health or health-related vision research. BRGs may propose
to apply basic bioengineering design-directed or hypothesis-drive
research to an important vision research area. Bioengineering Research
Partnership grants support multidisciplinary research teams applying
an integrative, systems approach to develop knowledge and/or methods
to prevent, detect, diagnose, or treat diseases of the eye and visual
system. Collaborative Research on Therapy for Visual Disorders grants
provide support to collaborative, multidisciplinary research focused
on the development of novel therapies to restore or prevent the
loss of function due to visual diseases and disorders. The Collaborative
Program on Retinal Degenerative Disease Research is a collaboration
with the Foundation Fighting Blindness to stimulate basic cellular,
molecular, genetic, and clinical research on retinal degenerative
diseases. The program on The Role of Growth Factors in the Development
of Diabetes Complications supports research directed toward an understanding
of the tissue- and cell-specific expression of growth factors in
the eye and of the molecular action of these growth factors in the
pathophysiology of ocular diabetic complications. Small Business
Innovation Research Phase I grants are awarded to establish the
technical merit and feasibility of a proposed research effort that
may lead to a commercial product or process. Phase II grants are
for the continuation of the research initiated in Phase I that is
likely to result in commercial products or processes. Only Phase
I awardees are eligible to apply for Phase II support. Small Business
Technology Transfer Research, Phase I grants are to determine the
scientific, technical, and commercial merit and feasibility of the
proposed cooperative effort that has potential for commercial application.
Phase II funding is based on results of research initiated in Phase
I and scientific and technical merit and commercial potential on
Phase II application. National Research Service Awards (NRSAs),
both individual and institutional, support training in vision research.
Some individuals who receive an NRSA may be obligated upon termination
of the award to comply with certain service and payback provisions.
The NIH Extramural Loan Repayment Programs provides payback of a
portion of eligible student loan debt of qualified health professionals
who agree to conduct clinical research.
ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS:
Applicant Eligibility:
Universities, colleges, hospitals, laboratories, federal institutions
and other public or private nonprofit and for-profit domestic institutions,
including small businesses, and State and local units of government
are eligible to make application for research grants, cooperative
agreements, and career development awards. Foreign institutions
may apply for research grants only. The grantee institution must
agree to administer the grant in accordance with prevailing regulations
and policies. Candidates for Mentored Clinical Scientist Development
Awards are restricted to those holding health professional degrees
in the clinical sciences (M.D., O.D., D.D.S., D.V.M., or equivalent).
NRSAs are provided for predoctoral and postdoctoral research training.
Individual NRSAs may be made for applicants who hold a professional
or scientific degree (M.D., Ph.D., O.D., D.D.S., D.V.M., Sc.D.,
D.Eng., or equivalent degree). Institutional NRSAs may be made for
both predoctoral and postdoctoral research training. Predoctoral
awardees must have completed the baccalaureate degree. All awardees
must be citizens of the United States, or have been admitted to
the U.S. for permanent residence prior to award. Individual NRSA
awardees must be nominated and sponsored by a Federal, public or
private nonprofit institution having staff and facilities suitable
to the proposed research training. Federal and for-profit organizations,
and State and local governments may not apply for an institutional
NRSA. Refer to the NIH Program Guidelines on NRSAs for further information.
The Small Business Innovation grants: SBIRs can be awarded only
to domestic small businesses (entities that are independently owned
and operated for profit, are not dominant in the field in which
research is proposed, and have not more than 500 employees). Primary
employment (more than one-half time) of the principal investigator
must be with the small business at the time of the award and during
the conduct of the proposed project. The research during both Phase
I and Phase II must be performed in the U.S. or its possessions.
Only Phase I awardees are eligible to receive Phase II support.
STTR grants can be awarded only to domestic small business concerns
(entities that are independently owned and operated for profit,
are not dominant in the field in which research is proposed and
have no more that 500 employees) which "partner" with a research
institution in cooperative research and development. At least 40
percent of the project is to be performed by the small business
concern and at least 30 percent by the research institution. In
both Phase I and Phase II, the research must be performed in the
U.S. and its possessions. Individuals applying for the NIH Loan
Repayment Programs must be engaged in patient oriented research
and be trained in a medical subspecialty as defined under Section
206 of Public Law 106-505. These individuals must be U.S. citizens,
U.S. citizen nationals, or lawfully admitted for permanent residence
in the U.S.; have a student loan debt which equals or exceeds 20
percent of their university compensation; have no Federal judgment
lien against their property arising from a Federal debt; and owe
no obligation of health professional service to the Federal government,
a State, or other entity unless deferrals are granted during the
length of their Loan Repayment Program service obligation.
Beneficiary Eligibility:
Any nonprofit or for-profit organization, company, or institution
engaged in biomedical research.
Credentials/Documentation:
(1) Research grants and cooperative agreements: Applicants applying
for research involving the use of human subjects must submit documentation
that all key personnel have received training in human subject
protection. No additional credentials or documentation are required
with application, except for those that the applicant feels will
help establish the scientific and technical merit and the programmatic
relevance of his/her application. (2) Individual NRSA applications:
The applicant's academic record, research experience, institutional
sponsorship, and the proposed area and plan of training must be
included in the application. (3) Institutional NRSA application:
The applicant institution must discuss the objectives, methodology
and resources for the research training program, the qualifications
and experience of directing staff, the criteria to be used in
selecting individuals for an award, and a detailed budget and
justification for the amount of grant funds requested. Costs will
be determined in accordance with the appropriate OMB Circular
or in accordance with HHS Regulations 45 CFR, Part 74, Subpart
Q. (4) For SBIR and STTR grants, the applicant organization (small
business concern) must present in a research plan an idea that
has potential for commercialization and furnish evidence that
scientific competence, experimental methods, facilities, equipment,
and funds requested are appropriate to carry out the plan. Grant
form PHS 350 (rev. 05/2000 is used to apply for SBIR and STTR
grants. Loan Repayment Program applicants must provide certification
of loan nondelinquent status, loan data verification, and an institutional
supporting statement.
Pre-application
Coordination: Applicants for core grants, clinical
vision research development awards, clinical study planning grants,
cooperative agreements for clinical studies or conferences, clinical
vision research development awards, small research grants for data
analyses, and bioengineering research partnerships should seek preapplication
coordination through contact with the National Eye Institute staff.
Applicants planning to submit a grant application requesting $500,000
or more in direct costs for any year are required to discuss their
eligibility with the NEI staff. This program is excluded from coverage
under E.O. 12372.
Application Procedure:
Standard application forms, as required by 45 CFR, Part 74 and
92, must be used for this program. Applicants to the Cooperative
Program on Retinal Degenerative Disease Research who wish to be
considered for funding by the FFB must submit a brief letter of
authorization. Prior to making formal application to the NRSA
programs, individual NRSA applicants must be nominated and sponsored
by a federal, public, or nonprofit institution having staff and
facilities appropriate to the proposed research program. An application
form, PHS-398 (Rev.4/98), for research grant and cooperative agreement
awards may be requested from the Division of Extramural Outreach
and Information, National Institutes of Health, 6701 Rockledge
Drive, MSC 7910, Bethesda, MD 20892-7910. Telephone: 301 435-0714,
e-mail: ASKNIH@odrockml.od.nih.gov and should be submitted to
the Center for Scientific Review, National Institutes of Health,
Bethesda, MD 20892. Supplemental instructions for preparing applications
for Core Grants, Mentored Clinical Scientist Development Awards,
Clinical Vision Research Development Awards, Clinical Study Planning
Grants, Small Research Grants for Data Analyses, and cooperative
agreements for clinical studies or conferences are available on
the internet at http://www.nei.nih.gov/ or they can be requested
from National Eye Institute staff. SBIR and STTR Grant Solicitations
and SBIR Contract Solicitation may be obtained electronically
through the NIH's "Small Business Funding Opportunities" home
page at http://www.nih.gov/grants/funding/sbir.htm on the World
Wide Web. The Solicitations include submission procedures, review
considerations, and grant application or contract proposal forms.
SBIR and STTR grant applications should be submitted to the Center
for Scientific Review, 6701 Rockledge Drive, Room 1040 - MSC 7710,
Bethesda, MD 20892-7710. Application forms and information concerning
the NRSA program are available from the Center for Scientific
Review, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD 20892, and
should be submitted to the same address. National Eye Institute
guidelines and supplemental instructions for preparing Institutional
NRSA applications are available on the World Wide Web at http://www.nei.nih.gov/
or can be obtained from the National Eye Institute, EPS 350, 6120
Executive Boulevard, MSC 7164, Bethesda, MD 20892-7164. This program
is subject to the provisions of 45 CFR 74 and 92 and OMB Circular
No. A-110 for nonprofit organizations, as applicable.
Award Procedure:
Applications are reviewed initially for scientific and technical
merit. A second level review of the programmatic relevance of
applications is provided by the National Advisory Eye Council.
Second level review of NRSA fellowship applications are reviewed
by a committee comprised of senior staff of the National Eye Institute.
Final approval is made by the Director, National Eye Institute.
Formal award notices are then transmitted to the appropriate institutional
official. All accepted SBIR/STTR applications are evaluated for
scientific and technical merit by an appropriate scientific peer
review panel and by the National Advisory Eye Council. All applications
receiving a priority score compete for available SBIR/STTR set-aside
funds on the basis of scientific and technical merit and commercial
potential of the proposed research, program relevance, and program
balance among the areas of research.
Deadlines:
New research grants and cooperative agreements: February 1, June
1, and October 1. Renewal, revised, and supplemental applications:
March 1, July 1, and November 1. Academic Research Enhancement
Award: January 25, May 25, September 25. NRSA Individual Postdoctoral
fellowship: April 5, August 5, and December 5. NRSA Individual
Predoctoral Fellowship for Minority Students or Students with
Disabilities: May 1 and November 15. NRSA Institutional: May 10.
SBIR and STTR: April 1, August 1, and December 1. Core Grants:
August 27. AIDS ASAP grants: January 2, May 1, and September 1.
Loan Repayment Program applications: February 1.
Range of Approval/Disapproval
Time: Approximately 6 to 9 months for Research
Grants, Mentored Clinical Scientist Development Awards, Clinical
Vision Research Development Awards, Clinical Study Planning Grants,
cooperative clinical studies or conferences, Core Grants, and
NRSA Institutional applications; from 6 to 7 months for NRSA individual
applications; and for SBIR, about 7-1/2 months.
Appeals:
A principal investigator may communicate to the staff of the National
Eye Institute any concerns he/she may have about the substantive
or procedural aspects of the review of an application.
Renewals:
Renewals of research grant or cooperative agreement support are
by competitive application and review. Mentored Clinical Scientist
Development Awards, Clinical Research Development Awards, Clinical
Study Planning Grants, Small Grants for Data Analysis, and Small
Grants for Pilot Research are non-renewable.
ASSISTANCE CONSIDERATIONS:
Formula and Matching
Requirements: This program has no statutory
formula or matching requirements.
Length and Time Phasing
of Assistance: Up to 5 years for research
grants and cooperative agreements, Mentored Clinical Scientist
Development Awards, Core Grants, Clinical Vision Research Development
Awards and NRSAs (Institutional). Academic Research Enhancement
Award, up to 3 years. Clinical Study Planning Grants: 1 year.
Up to 3 years for NRSA postdoctoral awards (Individual Awards
to individuals made through a NRSA (Institutional may total 8
years (5 years as a predoctoral and an additional 3 years as a
postdoctoral). Assistance is available for each budget period,
usually 1 year. SBIR: Normally, Phase I awards are for 6 months;
normally, Phase II awards are for 2 years. STTR: Normally, Phase
I awards are for 1 year; normally, Phase II awards are for 2 years.
Loan Repayment Program Awards are for two years with the opportunity
for renewal.
POST ASSISTANCE REQUIREMENTS:
Reports:
The grantee is responsible for annual progress reports. These are
required for program analysis as part of all continuation applications.
In addition, a final report is required to be filed within 90 days
of the termination of the grant. The final report includes an account
of progress made toward achievement of the originally stated aims;
a list of the results, positive and negative, that are considered
significant by the investigator; and a list of any publications
resulting from the projects. Also, for most projects a financial
status report is required 90 days after each competitive segment.
However, selected mechanisms such as cooperative agreements and
Institutional NRSAs require an annual financial status report. NRSAs
(Institutional) Statement of Appointment for each trainee selected
by the Program Director must be submitted to the National Eye Institute
for each year of training, not to exceed 3 years. Reports are required
after termination of the NRSAs to ascertain compliance with the
service and pay back provisions for each institutionally selected
trainee.
Audits:
In accordance with the provisions of OMB Circular No. A- 133 (Revised,
June 24, 1997), "Audits of States, Local Governments, and Nonprofit
Organizations," nonfederal entities that expend financial assistance
of $300,000 or more in Federal awards will have a single or a
program-specific audit conducted for that year. Nonfederal entities
that expend less than $300,000 a year in Federal awards are exempt
from Federal audit requirements for that year, except as noted
in Circular No. A-133. In addition, grants and cooperative agreements
are subject to inspection and audits by DHHS and other Federal
government officials. Loan Repayment Program awards will be audited
prior to the end of the contract or as needed.
Records:
Expenditures and other financial records must be retained for
3 years from the day on which the grantee submits the last expenditure
report for the report period.
FINANCIAL INFORMATION:
Account Identification:
75-0887-0-1-552.
Obligations:
(Grants and Cooperative Agreements) FY 01 $413,909; FY 02 est
$464,194,000; and FY 03 est $502,717,000. (NRSA): FY 01 $9,762,000;
FY 02 est $11,624,000; and FY 03 est $12,164,000. (SBIR and STTR):
FY 01 $12,096,000; FY 02 est $13,234,000; and FY 03 est $14,341,000.
Range
and Average of Financial Assistance:
Grants and cooperative agreements: $13,675 to $5,096,101. Average:
$302,628. NRSA (Institutional): $18,842 to $494,340. Average:
$160145. NRSA (Individual): $20,356 to $52,712. Average: $37,325.
SBIR Phase I: $$84,640 to $135,594. Average: 102,811. SBIR Phase
II: $150,593 to $555,256. Average: $388,841. STTR Phase I: $99,984
to $111,070. Average: $105,083. STTR Phase II: $245,726 to $245,726.
Average: $245,726.
In fiscal year 2001, this
program supported approximately 1,522 research grants, including
49 SBIR and STTR awards, and 267 NRSA awards. This program received
approximately 987 competing research grant applications in fiscal
year 2001, of which approximately 392 competing applications were
funded, with an estimated success rate of 39.7 percent. In fiscal
year 2002, the program anticipate to support 1,460 research grants,
including 54 SBIR and STTR awards, and 267 NRSA awards. These same
numbers are anticipated in fiscal year 2003. A report by the National
Advisory Eye Council, "Vision Research - A National Plan: 1999-2003,"
provides a comprehensive summary of the program's goals, objectives,
accomplishments, research budget, and program and management policies,
as well as statistical information on the incidence, prevalence,
and cost of visual disorders. Copies of this document are available
on the internet at http://www.nei.nih.gov or from: Office of Science
Policy and Legislation, National Eye Institute, Building 31, Room
6A25, 31 Center Drive, MSC 2510, Bethesda, MD 20892- 2510.
REGULATIONS, GUIDELINES, AND
LITERATURE:
42 CFR 52; 42 CFR 66;
45 CFR 74; 45 CFR 92. PHS Grants Policy Statement DHHS Publication
No. (OASH) 94-50,000 (Rev.) April 1, 1994, and Addendum effective
February 15, 1995; "NIH Guide for Grants and Contacts and Supplements."
National Eye Institute Guidelines are available for Support for
Clinical Trials in Vision Research, Participating Clinics in Multicenter
Clinical Trials, Clinical Study Planning Grant, Clinical Vision
Research Development Award, Small Research Grants for Data Analyses,
NRSA Institutional Research Training Grants, Mentored Clinical Scientist
Development Award, Core Grants for Vision Research, and Support
of Scientific Meetings. Grants will be available under the authority
of and administered in accordance with the PHS Grants Policy Statement
and Federal regulations at 42 CFR 52 and 42 USC 241; Omnibus Solicitation
of the Public Health Service for Small Business Innovation Research
(SBIR) Grant and Cooperative Agreement Applications. Omnibus Solicitation
of the National Institutes of Health for Small Business Technology
Transfer (STTR) Grant Applications.
INFORMATION CONTACTS:
Regional or Local
Office: Not applicable.
Headquarters Office:
Dr. Ralph J. Helmsen, Research Resources Officer, National Eye
Institute, National Institutes of Health, Department of Health
and Human Services, EPS 350, 6120 Executive Boulevard MSC 7164,
Bethesda, MD 20892-7164. Telephone: (301) 451-2020. Grants Management
Officer Contact: Mr. William W. Darby, Chief, Grants Management
Branch, National Eye Institute, National Institutes of Health,
Department of Health and Human Services, EPS 350, 6120 Executive
Boulevard MSC 7164 Bethesda, MD 20892-7164. Telephone: (301) 451-2020.
Use the same numbers for FTS. The National Eye Institute encourages
prospective applicants to visit its internet site at www.nei.nih.gov/.
Among the many recent additions to the site is an expanded "Funding
Information/Grants and Contracts" section which contains all National
Eye Institute application guidelines and internet links to relevant
NIH sites.
Web Site Address: http://www.nei.nih.gov
EXAMPLES OF FUNDED PROJECTS:
(1) Retinal Diseases:
Projects include studies of the development, molecular and cell
biology, molecular genetics, and metabolism of the photoreceptor
cells and their dependence on the underlying retinal pigment epithelium;
the mechanism of the retina's response to light and the initial
processing of information that is transmitted to the visual centers
of the brain; the pathogenesis of diabetic retinopathy; the fundamental
causes of and etiologic factors responsible for uveitis; the molecular
genetic mechanisms underlying retinoblastoma and ocular melanoma;
the characterization at the molecular level of the genes responsible
for retinitis pigmentosa, age-related macular degeneration, and
related disorders; and the cellular and molecular events that accompany
retinal detachment. (2) Corneal Diseases: Projects include studies
of the regulation of genes that express proteins unique to corneal
tissue; the details of the macromolecular and supramolecular assembly
of extracellular corneal matrices; the characterization of cytokines
and cell surface receptors which interact with corneal cells, pathogens,
and blood borne cells; the pathogenesis of corneal infections; the
mechanisms that maintain corneal hydration and transparency; the
physiologic basis for immune privilege in the cornea; corneal development,
growth, and wound healing; the biomechanics of the cornea; the characterization
of genes responsible for corneal dystrophy; and, the correction
of refractive errors. (3) Lens and Cataract: Projects include studies
of lens development, characterization of changes in lens physiology
and biochemistry related to aging and cataract formation, the identification,
at the cellular and molecular level, of those components and physiological
processes required to maintain transparency, studies to identify
what controls lens shape and its accommodating dynamics, the molecular
and cellular characterization of the control of lens cell division
and differentiation; genetic studies to map and identify cataract
genes; studies to describe the structure and function of lens crystallins;
studies to identify those insults that lead to cataract formation
such as oxidative stress, and, the role of aldose reductase in human
cataractogenesis. (4) Glaucoma: Projects include studies of the
genetics of glaucoma, characterizing at the cellular and molecular
level the extracellular matrix proteins of the trabecular meshwork;
elucidating the basic mechanisms that control aqueous humor dynamics;
designing better pharmacologic agents to modulate aqueous humor
secretion and outflow; and characterization of mechanisms of optic
nerve damage and the cell biology of retinal ganglion cell death.
(5) Strabismus, Amblyopia, and Visual Processing: Projects include
studies of the function of the neural pathways from the eye to the
brain, the central processing of visual information, visual perception,
optical properties of the eye, functioning of the pupil, and control
of the ocular muscles; congenital, developmental, and degenerative
abnormalities of the visual sensorimotor system, particularly strabismus
and amblyopia. Additional emphasis is placed on and support provided
for research on optic neuropathies, eye movement disorders, and
the development of myopia.
CRITERIA FOR SELECTING PROPOSALS:
The major elements in
the initial scientific and technical review of most applications
include an assessment of significance, approach, innovation, investigator
training and experience, and the scientific environment. In addition
to these criteria, in accordance with NIH policy, all applications
will also be reviewed with respect to the following: the adequacy
of plans to include both genders, minorities, and their subgroups
as appropriate for the scientific goals of the research; the reasonableness
of the proposed budget and duration in relation to the proposed
research; and, the adequacy of the proposed protection for humans,
animals or the environment, to the extent they may be adversely
affected by the project proposed in the application. A second level
review of the programmatic relevance of most applications is provided
by the National Advisory Eye Council. The following criteria will
be used in considering the scientific and technical merit of SBIR/STTR
Phase I grant applications: (1) The soundness and technical merit
of the proposed approach; (2) the qualifications of the proposed
principal investigator, supporting staff, and consultants; (3) the
technological innovation of the proposed research; (4) the potential
of the proposed research for commercial application; (5) the appropriateness
of the budget requested; (6) the environment; and (7) where applicable,
the adequacy of assurances detailing the proposed means for (a)
safeguarding human or animal subjects, and/or (b) protecting against
or minimizing any adverse effect on the environment. Phase II grant
applications will be reviewed based upon the following criteria:
(1) The degree to which the Phase I objectives were met and feasibility
demonstrated; (2) the scientific and technical merit of the proposed
approach for achieving the Phase II objectives; (3) the qualifications
of the proposed principal investigator, supporting staff, and consultants;
(4) the technological innovation, originality, or societal importance
of the proposed research; (5) the potential of the proposed research
for commercial application; (6) the reasonableness of the budget
requested for the work proposed; (7) the adequacy and suitability
of the facilities and research environment; and (8) where applicable,
the adequacy of assurances detailing the proposed means for (a)
safeguarding human or animal subjects, and/or (b) protecting against
or minimizing any adverse effect on the environment.